Update: Several major brokerage firms have recently announced they will no longer be charging commissions for standard US-based stocks and Exchange Traded Funds (ETFs).
We have updated our rankings based on this new information. It’s exciting to see how the online brokerage community has grown by leaps and bounds in the last few years. This innovation is great for investors participating in online stock trading.
The competition has forced innovation, cheap online stock trades, and additional features to track gains, losses, and more such as:
- Educational and Training Centers
- Articles
- Videos
- Free Webinars
- Chat Rooms and Forums
- Social Networking
- Free Tax Software
Not all of these features are available at all discount brokerage firms, and some stockbrokers offer better value than others.
Our goal is to show you some of the best value in the discount brokerage space and some of the top features they offer.
We have focused on the more popular firms that consistently appear in the industry awards reviews, including those by SmartMoney and Kiplinger’s.
This brokerage comparison chart will give you some basic information on pricing structures, and below the comparison chart are some unique features of each of these online brokerage firms.
Hopefully, you can use this information to find the best online discount brokerage for your needs.
Best Online Discount Brokerages
| Discount Brokerage Firm | Our Review | Cost Per Stock Trade | Cost Per Options Trade |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ally Invest | Our Ally Invest Review | $0.00 | $0.00 + $0.50 |
| TD Ameritrade | Our TD Ameritrade Review | $0.00 | $0.00 + $0.65 |
| Firstrade | Our Firstrade Review | $0.00 | $0.00 + $0.00 |
| E*TRADE | Our E*TRADE Review | $0.00 | $0.00 + $0.65 ($0.00 + $0.50 for active traders) |
| Betterment | Our Betterment Review | $0.00 | NA |
| M1 Finance | Our M1 Finance Review | $0.00 | NA |
| Schwab | $0.00 | $0.00+$0.65 |
Comparing Discount Brokerage Features
To determine which broker is right for you, we suggest evaluating your trading habits and needs and comparing various features such as:
- Available Investments
- Account Types (IRA, taxable accounts, 529 plans, trusts, banking services, and more)
- Commissions (cost per trade)
- Options Trading (availability, and cost per option)
- Online only vs. Brick & Mortar
- Availability of Broker Assisted Trades
- Maintenance Fees, if any (most investment providers on this list do not charge any additional fees)
- Education & Investment Training
- Tax Software for tracking investments, long-term & short-term capital gains, and tax-loss harvesting
- Customer Service
More in-depth information on these topics follows the overviews of our favorite discount brokerages.
Highest Rated Discount Brokerages
Each of these brokers has some features which set it apart from the others, but generally, our recommendations are as follows:
Ally Invest
Ally Bank acquired TradeKing, which is a personal favorite of mine. I opened my TradeKing account over ten years ago!
Thankfully, they transitioned into good hands. Ally Bank brings a tradition of excellence to the banking industry, and I’m excited to see where they take this partnership.
Ally Invest offers the following features:
- a slick and easy-to-use interface
- cheap stock trades
- an exceptional learning center
- free webinars
- free access to Maxit Tax Manager to track your gains and losses
- and more
Ally Invest’s pricing structure is among the best in the business for discount stock trades, including for investors who prefer to trade options.
For more information or to open an Ally Invest account, read our full review of Ally Invest or visit the Ally Invest website.
Open a Brokerage Account with Ally Invest
TD Ameritrade
TD Ameritrade is among the top-ranked online brokers, according to third-party ratings by Barron’s and Kiplinger’s.
TD Ameritrade also joined the trend of brokerages offering commission-free equity trades by removing the commissions on all online stock trades. They also offer over 2,300 commission-free ETFs.
Not only do you get commission-free trades, but you get one of the industry’s top education and training platforms and one of the top-rated research platforms. (see our review here)
Add in no account minimums, no monthly maintenance fees, and the ability to make trades online, on your mobile phone, or at one of over 100 physical locations, and you have a winning combination.
For more information or to open a TD Ameritrade account, visit https://www.tdameritrade.com/.
Open a Brokerage Account with TD Ameritrade
Firstrade
Founded in 1985, Firstrade.com has one of the longest legacies of discount brokerage firms.
Firstrade gives stock traders and investors low commissions, low margin rates, and a three-second execution guarantee.
Firstrade offers:
- regular brokerage accounts
- retirement accounts
- Education Savings Accounts
All of these come with no minimum initial deposit and no maintenance or inactivity fees.
Firstrade has access to over 11,000 mutual funds and offers new customers up to 100 free trades.
Firstrade no longer charges commissions on standard stock trades, and their options contracts are among the least expensive among the brokerages reviewed by our site, coming in at $0.00 plus $0.00 per contract. You can’t beat free!
You can read our Firstrade review for more information, or visit their website to open an account.
Open a Brokerage Account with Firstrade
E*TRADE
E*TRADE offers a full-service brokerage firm and an online bank, which makes it easy to link accounts and transfer funds to and from. E*TRADE also recently introduced $0 Base Rate Commissions for Online Stock, ETF, and Options Trades.
You can’t beat the pricing on commission-free trades! Add this to its award-winning platform, and you have a recipe for success.
E*TRADE has won numerous awards for its brokerage services and online savings accounts. They also offer many services and features not found with many other online discount brokerages, including their E*TRADE Core Portfolios.
New customers can get a cash bonus of up to $2,500 days when they open a new non-retirement brokerage account and fund it or transfer securities into it within 60 days.
Finally, no account minimums exist when you open an account with E*TRADE.
$0 Commissions for online stock, ETF & options trades plus get up to $2,500 at E*TRADE today
Open a Brokerage Account with E*TRADE
Betterment
Different than most of the brokerages on the list, Betterment is a full-fledged robo advisor. If you like that aspect of M1 but are comfortable with being even less involved in managing your investments, Betterment is ideal.
Rather than charging for individual trades, Betterment has no trading fees but instead charges an annual fee of .25%, which increases to .40% at the premium level and gives you unlimited access to Betterment’s CFPs.
Betterment invests your funds in stock and bond ETFs and offers tax-smart investments, automatic rebalancing, retirement planning, and advising.
Look at our full Betterment review and visit their site to open an account.
Open a Brokerage Account with Betterment
M1 Finance
M1 Finance is an up-and-coming platform making waves in the robo advising community, uniquely blending automated investing and self-managed accounts. With M1 you can choose from professionally crafted investment “pies” made of ETFs and stocks.
Beyond those 60 templates, you can create your portfolio, selecting investments to target your financial goals and interests.
Then M1 keeps your accounts balanced like a typical robo-advisor to keep you on track for your goals, free of fees. When you sign up for an account, there is no minimum deposit; however, you’ll need $100 to start investing or $500 with an IRA.
M1 gives you flexibility, free account management, and the opportunity to play a hand in your investments, excitingly melding conventional brokerages and robo-advisors.
Check out our M1 Finance review and sign up for an account today.
Open a Brokerage Account with M1 Finance
Schwab
Charles Schwab has combined the platform of OptionsXpress with their research and support to offer investors a comprehensive trading space. Like many other brokerage firms, Schwab offers commission-free trading for standard US-based stock trades.
Options trades are commission-free, with a $0.65 charge for each contract.
Schwab has no inactivity or maintenance fees, regardless of how much you have in your account, and does not charge for streaming quotes or standard withdrawals.
Schwab Investing offers:
- free webinars
- free trading tools
- free advanced research
- the option of a personal coaching program
For a limited time, you can also get a $100 sign-up bonus when you open a new account, fund it with a minimum of $500 and make a minimum of 3 trades in the first 12 months of enrollment.
In Nov. 2019, Schwab agreed to purchase TD Ameritrade. The merger was approved in late 2020.
Which Investment Firm is Best?
As you can see from the above comparison chart, there is a wide range of prices and features with these brokerages, which should cover just about anyone.
I recommend reading the section below to help you learn how to compare the different brokerages and determine which online discount brokerage is the best for your needs.
We also have a list of prominent IRA providers if you consider opening an IRA.
How Do Online Brokerages Work?
A brokerage account is a financial account similar to the accounts you have with a bank. With a brokerage account, you deposit funds with an investment firm, usually by a transfer from your existing bank account.
Once funds are added to your brokerage account, you can put the money to work using the brokerage’s trading platform to invest those funds in the market.
The assets you buy with your cash can be anything brokerage offers, including stocks, bonds, ETFs, and even cryptocurrency.
Your online brokerage account will display your holdings (the assets you’ve purchased) and your cash balance (your buying power).
If you invest in something that gains value, you can sell it, and the profits will be deposited in your online brokerage account.
How Much Money Do You Need To Start Investing?
Many brokers offer accounts with no minimums and access to fractional shares, so you can start investing with any amount of money. However, it will influence how you approach the market if you don’t have a lot of money to invest.
You could also consider using options to leverage your dollars with a directional bet on the market or a specific stock. Still, this strategy is best reserved for a small portion of your risk capital.
When investing with small sums, consistency is the key to building wealth. If you can regularly put a set amount of money into the market, it will smooth market effects because you’ll be buying dips and peaks as the market goes up and down.
More Investment Options Now
You can still invest this way, and many people prefer the personal touch a one-on-one broker can offer compared to seeking advice and access to trades online.
However, visiting with an in-person broker may not be the best choice for beginners who have very little to invest or who aren’t serious enough about investing to start a personal relationship.
Online brokerages remove this middle man (or middle woman) from the equation for the most part. You’re still dealing with a website or an algorithm, and you’ll still pay some fees and commissions in many cases.
But with so many online tools available, it’s much easier to experiment with different platforms and even invest with several different brokerages.
Some Brokerages Do Both
A lot of traditional brokerages have joined the online investing community, combining the flexibility of online trading with the tradition of trust their brands represent.
Some of these big names won’t appear on the lists below because they may require a large initial deposit or charge more expensive fees.
Big investment names have gotten into robo-advising as well. Robo advisors can cost even less as they let computer algorithms analyze, re-balance, and shape your portfolio.
For this post, we’ll lump robo-advisors and online brokerages together to keep things simple.
No matter your needs, you have a lot of options.
Do Brokers Offer Mobile Platforms?
Some online brokers have incredible mobile apps delivering nearly all the same features as their desktop counterparts.
For example, TD Ameritrade customers can pick between the more robust thinkorswim mobile app aimed at traders or the standard TD Ameritrade app for less active investors, with the features of each adjusted for the intended user.
What Makes a Broker the Best?
Naming the best of anything usually includes some opinions, and that’s certainly the case in this post.
Still, even opinions should be based on fact. So here’s what matters to us as we start naming our best brokerages:
- Ease of Use: If you have to explain how a system works, you usually need a new one. Traders, especially beginners, have enough to worry about without dealing with a clunky interface or a confusing website. Also, consider the brokerage’s technology offered and if it fits your investing style as a long-term investor or an active trader.
- Research and Education: Look for a broker who can assist you with quality research and educational tools to help you develop as an investor and help you make winning decisions in the markets.
- Transparency: How much will you pay per trade? If you’re unsure, or if you’ve been burned with surprise fees on your statement, you aren’t typically a happy trader. We considered only brokerages with easy-to-find fee structures.
- Access to Information: You also should have easy access to how a specific security has performed over the past couple of years. You shouldn’t have to leave your online trading platform to do research in another browser window or tab. And you certainly shouldn’t have to stop and make a phone call. If you choose to, that’s fine. But your platform shouldn’t require you to hunt for info.
- Affordability: Some excellent investment platforms charge a lot or require a considerable opening balance. Though they offer quality products, we won’t include them on these lists because we’re focusing more on beginning investors.
- Access to Live Customer Support: Some brokers have excellent live support, often available by phone and chat 24/7. Others focus more on technology and have minimal customer service available via email or text chat.
For the most part, every broker on our lists below met most or all minimum requirements from the criteria above. If you don’t see your favorite broker listed, it’s possible the platform didn’t meet one of our requirements.
So enough explaining — let’s get to the lists.
How to Compare Online Brokers
Not all online brokerages are created equal. Here are some of the major areas to consider when comparing online brokerages:
Commissions and Other Trading Related Expenses
One of the first features many investors look at first is cost.
While lower is generally better, the overall cost per trade may not be the most critical factor if you are not a frequent trader. Saving $1 per trade on less than ten trades per year won’t significantly impact your bottom line.
On the other hand, day traders and other high-volume investors will want to look for the lowest commission per trade and will also want to compare other expenses, discounts for high-volume traders, etc.
Here are some of the different factors to consider when comparing commission costs between online brokerages:
- Commissions for Market or Limit Trades
- Options Trades
- Automatic Investing or Reinvesting
- Cost of Buying No Load Mutual Funds
- ETF trade fees
- Cost of trading on margin
Other common costs to compare:
Assisted Trades. Some brokerages charge extra if you need personal assistance when making a trade.
Most platforms are easy enough to manage without this added feature, so you won’t need it for every trade.
Just be sure to understand what the trading fee will be so you don’t have any surprises (and be sure to check with the broker’s online knowledgebase or customer service before placing a broker-assisted trade – you can usually handle most trades on your own).
Account Minimums & Inactivity Fees. Some brokerages require customers to maintain a minimum balance to avoid fees.
Others may charge customers for inactivity if they don’t make a certain number of trades within a set time frame.
I am primarily a buy & hold investor, so I prefer to avoid brokerages that nickel and dime customers with these fees. Most discount brokerage firms don’t charge these fees, but be aware that some brokers do.
Differential Pricing for Commissions. Many brokerages charge a flat fee per trade, while others offer differential pricing.
This is common for accounts that maintain a certain minimum account balance or exceed a set number of trades per month, quarter, or year.
For example, some companies may charge $6.95 per trade or $4.95 when you make at least 30 trades per quarter.
Investment Availability
Most brokerage firms allow investors to trade just about any stock in the major US markets. But there are different types of investments you may wish to trade that may or may not be available at every brokerage firm.
Good examples include certain mutual funds and ETFs. Here are some more factors to consider when comparing discount brokerages:
Mutual Fund and ETF Availability. Not all mutual funds and ETFs are available at all brokerages.
Many major mutual fund and ETF families are widely available but check with your brokerage before assuming you have access to everything.
Someone like Vanguard, for example, has some of the best mutual fund families and ETFs available. They also have options for a standard brokerage account of their new Personal Advisor Service.
Dividend Reinvestment Plans. Many investors prefer to automatically reinvest their dividends to continue having their money work for them without thinking about it.
However, not all brokerages make it easy to do this.
If you want to reinvest your dividends automatically, look for brokerage companies offering free Dividend Reinvestment Plans (DRIPS). These plans allow investors to reinvest their dividends automatically without being charged with another commission.
Be sure to look for brokers that will enable investors to purchase fractional shares of companies. Otherwise, you won’t be able to put your entire dividend to use.
Automatic Investment Plans. Some investors prefer to automatically invest the same amount of money each month in the same stock, bond, or mutual fund.
This is very similar to investing in your 401k at work.
This works best for investors who regularly have a little extra cash to invest each month. This feature allows investors to create their investment schedule and stick to it.
Look for an investment firm that doesn’t charge for this feature.
Types of Investment Accounts Offered
Most brokerage firms offer some or all of the following types of investments:
- Taxable Investment Accounts (individual and joint)
- Individual Retirement Accounts – Traditional IRA, Roth IRA, Rollover IRA, SEP IRA, SIMPLE IRA
- Coverdell ESA
- Custodial Accounts
- Partnerships
- Trusts
- and more
Be sure to check with the brokerage if you need a different type of account, such as an account for a minor, a charitable trust, a small business retirement plan, Solo 401k, or another type of investment account.
Tools & Services
This is perhaps the most exciting area that separates the different online brokerages.
Many firms offer a variety of online tools and services, including educational and training resources, webinars, advanced stock filters, research tools, real-time quotes, advanced analysis, cost-basis tracking for tax purposes, and much more.
Full Service, Banking, and Other Features. Some brokerage firms are willing to hold your hand, while others expect you to be able to handle everything more or less on your own.
Some brokerages offer full-service banking. This can be convenient, as you can keep all your savings, checking, and investments under one roof.
Mobile Trading Platforms & Apps. Most brokerages now offer apps for your smartphone or tablet.
Not everyone wants to trade on the go, but having that flexibility can help you avoid being trapped behind a desk and give you the ability to take advantage of market movements when you’re out and about.
Promotional Offers and Sign-Up Bonuses
The brokerage community is very competitive. Many brokerage firms are willing to give new customers a bonus for opening a new brokerage account.
Common promotions include:
- Free stock trades – usually limited to a certain number or time frame,
- Cash bonus – often a flat rate for a new funded account or a tiered bonus based on the amount of the initial deposit
- Other bonus – I’ve seen promotional offers that include free iPads or Kindles, free GPS units, computers, and computer monitors, and more.
- Transfer fee reimbursement – most brokerages charge an ACAT Transfer fee to transfer your assets out of their brokerage. ACAT transfer fee refunds are a popular signup bonus because they remove barriers to moving funds to a new brokerage.
Customer Service and User Reviews
Don’t overlook customer service.
Many brokerage companies offer 24-7 customer service, while others may have more limited hours. You should also consider whether they offer phone support, chat, email, or other service forms.
Individual reviews are also critical. We do our best to review various products and services on this website. But our use and needs may differ from yours. It’s generally a good idea to consider multiple sources.
And, if possible, give the brokerage a test drive before committing all your investments to their service. One way to do this is to see if the brokerage firm offers a “play” account, where you can open an account and make stock trades with play money while you learn how their platform operates.
Many firms offer these types of accounts for free.
Another option is to open an account and test the waters before making actual live trades. Again, the purpose is to familiarize yourself with the platform before moving the bulk of your investments to that company.
Choose Your Brokerage Based on Your Needs
Investing is personal. And every investor may have different needs.
The high-volume trader may value certain features or commission structures, while the buy-and-hold investor may prefer a brokerage that offers other features, such as full-service banking. The above feature lists should give you a good starting point to consider which features are essential to you.
Use your personal feature list to narrow your choice to the best option for your needs. All the mentioned brokerage firms on this page should also be a good starting point, as they all offer something unique.
Best Brokerages For Low Starting Balances
When you’re just curious about investing, you shouldn’t have to come up with several thousand dollars to experiment.
The following platforms let you into the game without requiring a big up-front balance:
- Acorns
- Merrill Edge
- Robinhood
Best Brokerages For Low Trading Fees
Some investment firms let you invest without a large opening balance, but they charge high per-trade fees or commissions. It’s tough to learn the ropes when each trade costs $10 or when you’re robo takes a noticeable cut from your account each month.
Consider these platforms to save money on fees:
- M1 Finance
- Ally Invest
- Charles Schwab
Best Brokerages For Beginners
Many new investors like to learn as they go, and nothing teaches quite like an expensive mistake. Still, it’s even better to learn lessons without losing money.
These brokers can help smooth out the learning curve:
- Betterment
- E*Trade
- Zacks Trade
Best Brokers for Ease of Use
If you value an intuitive interface, consider these online brokers:
- TD Ameritrade
- FirstTrade
Do You Have More Than One Brokerage Account?
Many investors have more than one brokerage account.
There can be good reasons for this, including specialized trading needs, taking advantage of lower trading costs, utilizing premium features or services through a different broker, avoiding the expense or time involved with consolidating accounts, or other reasons.
Having multiple trading accounts can have benefits, but it can also complicate your finances.
For example, it’s one more account to look at when calculating your net worth, one more set of investments to deal with when re-balancing your assets, more sets of tax forms, etc. I can’t help you with the taxes, but I can help you with the first two problems.
If you are dealing with multiple accounts, linking your investment and other financial accounts to an account aggregator is highly recommended. These software programs will automatically link all your assets to show you your net worth and other valuable information.
Some will even show you your asset allocation and recommend how and where to rebalance your portfolio.
We have a list of free online tools to help you do this. But I’ll skip to the punch line and recommend the one I use – Personal Capital.
Personal Capital is free, easy to use. It will help you understand your total financial picture, including your net worth, asset allocation, how much you pay in fees, and where you can rebalance to get your portfolio in shape. It’s 100% online and uses bank-level security features to track your investments.
Can I Buy Stocks Without a Broker?
Yes, but it is not a common approach these days.
A few companies still offer direct stock purchase plans that allow you to buy shares directly from the company. Companies administer these plans according to internal rules, and some are only open to company employees.
These plans initially helped investors avoid brokerage fees, but the rise of online discount brokers with zero fees has removed this barrier, making the direct stock purchase plan somewhat archaic.
Visit the Personal Capital website to learn more or to open a FREE account.
About Post Author
Comments:
About the comments on this site:
These responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.
tamba says
Hey Ryan, I just start it to trade, no experience at all. I wish someone can help me how to start it and which one of the stocks I can start with. Please tell me about your experience with SOGOTRADE. or other experience
Dwayne S Dunston says
I am looking to open my first brokerage account. I know I want to trade daily and often, the feedback from everyone was truly helpful. Thank you Ryan
Bryce @ Save and Conquer says
I learned my lesson years ago that I am not a stock trader, or a trader of any kind of investment vehicle. I am a buy and hold investor. Given that, I still want to have the lowest transaction costs as well as lowest recurring fees while holding a fund or ETF. Vanguard low-cost index funds are hard to beat, but a couple Schwab ETFs cost less for purchasing and holding their Vanguard-comparable total stock market (SCHB) and total bond market (SCHZ). The ETFs are free to buy through a Schwab account, and the annual expense ratios are 0.04% and 0.05%, respectively.
Ryan Guina says
I’m in the same boat, Bryce – I’m a buy and hold person. I have Vanguard for most of my investments, simply because I have been with them for so long and they offer everything I need. Schwab, Fidelity, and several other companies also offer wonderful alternatives to Vanguard. I don’t think you can go wrong with any of them. Just look for the one that best meets your needs.
But if you do like to trade individual stocks, the discount brokers are often better options as they tend to offer lower cost trades, more tools, and a better interface for trading.
Jtrader says
I disagree. In my opinion there are 3 things that matter in todays competitive ‘daytrading’ or ‘swingtrading’ world.
1) Customer Service
2) low costs (low commissions with no fees, hidden or otherwise)
3) fast execution.
From the moment I opened my account at Lightspeed the customer service has been outstanding. The customer service rep, Jhoel, responded (and continues to respond) to every email, usually within minutes! Not only that, but I believe he is ‘assigned’ to my account. This means that I don’t have to explain or re-explain the issue to a new customer service rep each time. He is polite, knowledgeable and efficient. This means you have a rep who works with you in an ongoing basis, understands issues and develops a rapport with the customer. This should be an industry standard and Lightspeed does this for free. Yes, Web Trader IS a no frills platform, but there are also NO fees of any kind except the occasional SEC fee (to date I have paid just 5 cents on some transactions!) – no ‘maintenance’ fees, no ‘minimum trades per quarter’ (inactivity) fees, no platform fees, only a small minimum balance is required to avoid any fees (I think $5000?) and no BS! They also charge $3 per trade. Hello? I am an active trader, sometimes I don’t trade for a week or two, other times when conditions are ripe I may make 20 trades in 1 day. The fact that there is no pressure to trade (no fees at ALL) as well as some of the lowest per trade costs makes this a no brainer. I make appx 1000 trades a year, so lets do simple math. If I go with a company that calls itself a discount broker with no inactivity, maintenance or other fees like Firstrade for example (which also has no kind of fees, but has the WORST customer service I’ve ever seen, and lousy executions), they charge ‘ONLY’ 6.95 per trade. This means at year’s end I would spend $6,950 in commission with them, and pay only $3,000 with Lightspeed. This is simple math; a savings of $3950 a year, or over $329 per month, and if I trade more, I will save even more. That’s untaxed money added to your net profit.
As far as the ACH, I have been able to transfer in money with no problem, and while I am in the middle of setting up the ACH withdrawal (I mailed in their form), it can be done if you simply mail in the form and follow the instructions provided. I have not actually done an ACH withdrawal yet, but based on my experience with customer service (which in my experience has been the BEST I have ever experienced at any broker, and I’ve been with a few), I’m sure it will be no problem. By the way, did I mention they even have a live chat with operators who can see your account and answer questions in LIVE TIME? Yes Web Trader doesn’t have flashy graphics, and I think they need to improve by making a real time balance and begin pre/after hours trading abilities, but if I want flashy graphics I’ll play video games. If your a grown up and want to have REAL customer service, some of the lowest rates on trades, fast execution and a way to make it easier to make money, I recommend Lightspeed WebTrader and the team of people over there!
Sim says
another thing that makes tradeking more attractive than zecco because they have a full fledged iphone and blackberry app. something thats going to be more & more of an utmost necessity in coming days .. very less brokerages in the same price range has that.. something very notable… seriously thinking about moving to tradeking from zecco..
Ryan says
Sim, I moved from Zecco to TradeKing. The individual trades are slightly more expensive, but not enough that it made a difference for me. I prefer TradeKing’s tools and interface. That said, investing is a very personal matter, and both companies offer investors a great product and a ton of value. I can’t imagine what it would have cost to get these types of tools 5 or 10 years ago (if they even could have been done!).
Tee says
Hey Ryan, I wanted to find out if you know any good online broker that can be used to buy commodities (oil, cocoa, etc). Do most brokerages trade mutual funds or only single stocks? Thank for the great website.
Ryan says
Tee, Zecco and most discount broker offer a wide variety of mutual funds. I’m not sure which (if any) discount brokers offer commodities. However, you may find they offer ETFs or mutual funds based on commodities.
Jeremy says
I think SOGOTRADE is pretty good. It only cost $3 to make a trade (unlimited shares). They have good online and phone support, quick execution and a good inventory of shares that you can short! Oh and you only need $500 to open your account. You also get 100 free trades when you open your account. Can’t beat that.
Dan says
Just read your post Alan, Why not just have a TD Ameritrade / Think or Swim account with a small amount of money in it so that you can use all the free tools. TD Ameritrade has no yearly fees. Then use TradeKing for your actual trades.
Ryan says
That’s a great idea, Dan. I can see why some people would prefer not to do that – for example, if they don’t trade often or prefer to have as few open accounts as possible. But otherwise this idea could save money in the long run.
Alan says
I am in the process of closing my TradeKing and Zecco accounts. I don’t believe the $5 you save trading with them is work the lack of services.
There were a couple things that really bothered me with TradeKing. A wire transfer is cash money. However, if you wire money into TradeKing, and then need to get part of it back, they will not let you take out your money until after 10 days have passed from the time they received your wire. They are simply holding onto your clear cash to float your money and that is pretty crappy of them to do that. The second thing that I didn’t know when I opened my account with them is that they do not let you margin the leveraged ETF shares. That was a big surprise and a deal breaker for me. That is what lead to the surprise of them holding onto my cash that I wired to them for 1o days until I could get it back! That is crazy and for that policy alone I would not trade with them ever again.
If you really must save $5 per trade over better options, and you are going to decide between TradeKing and Zecco, I’d say TradeKing is the better choice of the two evils. Zecco is really bare bones; no pre or after hours trading allowed, no way to trade on mobile platforms, no service after hours, and a poor trading platform without any advanced order entry options. For example, you can’t enter an order triggers order with Zecco. (Say you want to automatically put in a stop order once your buy order is filled, you can’t do that with Zecco.) I had a bad experience trading a very leveraged ETF on 4x margin where the system would not let me enter my stop order. It could have been very serious if the market moved against me while I repeatedly tried to get the system to accept my order.
I’ve moved both my Zecco and TradeKing accounts over to TD Waterhouse. They charge $10 instead of about $5 that TradeKing and Zecco charges. If $5 per trade is going to make or break you, I don’t think you should be trading. I suggest you download the ThinkorSwim software (free) and check it out. It will blow you away. You can paper trade with a $100,000 account to try out the trading platform. For me the advanced real time streaming charts and advanced order capabilities at TD Waterhouse is way worth the extra $5 a trade. I’m really surprised the ThinkorSwim software is free. It blows away the streaming charts at TradeKing. At TradeKing you have to have a minimum of 25 trades per month to use their real time streaming charts. Try ThinkorSwim, you’ll love it. I run it with dual monitors and it gives me a very nice package of charts, news, and very advanced trade entry options. ThinkorSwim was the #1 rated internet broker and they have now merged with TD Waterhouse which was the #1 rated discount broker. Can’t go wrong with that combo.
I was drawn to the lower commissions at Zecco and then moved to TradeKing because of the extremely limited trading platform at Zecco. But it quickly became apparent that you get what you pay for and the extra $5 a trade at TD Ameritrade is well worth it for all the free tools, advanced orders, and real time streaming charts you get. With them you can even put in orders like “If the DOW falls by 3% buy TZA at market.”
PS – Just saw the post from Brad. TOS stands for ThinkorSwim. I agree 100% with him. Zecco and TradeKing is really amateur hour stuff.
Philly says
How can you leave out Firstrade from this comparison? $6.95 trades and free dividend reinvestment.
Wojciech @ Fiscal Fizzle says
I use Schwab almost exclusively now, although I’ve had accounts at most of the other brokerages at some point in the last 10 years. I invest primarily in no-fee funds, so costs were not that much of an issue for me – the choice of funds was.
One thing I found particularly helpful when deciding on a brokerage were Consumer Reports ratings. They were pretty much in line with my own experience of the various companies.
Ryan says
Thanks for the tips, Wojciech! I haven’t checked out Consumer Reports for brokerages yet, but I did some online research on blogs and forums. I curerntly use Zecco and TradeKing, but prefer TradeKing overall.
My Journey says
I used to use SogoTrade cause they were the cheapest and allowed for Dividend Reinvestment and Fractional shares….and boom they decided to stop so now I have everything at TradeKing.
Make sure of the features a site has in conjunction with the price per trade.
DDFD at DivorcedDadFrugalDad says
Nice analysis!
My view is that if you know your style it will help you choose wisely, are you a daytrader or a buy and hold kind of guy or gal?
Chad says
Why nobody talks about sogotrade? This is still the best website for only 3 dollars a trade/option. Sogotrade is not as good as tradeking, but it’s better than zecco. OK! zecco’s used to have a good interface, but its no good now due to a new change that makes it a little bit confusing. Sogotrade web interface is not really good, but you can get used to it because if you trade a lot like me. Sogotrade is not a nobody like zecco, it comes from a big broker and not a broken bank underinvestigation by the us gov. Tradeking requires little document to open an account there, but it has a fun interface. At the end, all cheap one line trade brokers are fast. Choose the one that you like. I chose Sogotrade!
Ryan says
Chad: I have never used SoGoTrade, which is why I cannot compare them to TradeKing, Zecco, or ShareBuilder – three online brokerage accounts I have used before.
Zecco received so much attention and press because they offered free trades to virtually everyone – though that is not the case anymore. Of the three I mentioned, TradeKing is my favorite because of the interface, free tools and education, and the low prices.
Ryan says
Thanks, Steve. From what I understand, TradeKing usually does a giveaway offer about once a year. They did it in October and November of last year, so it may be awhile before they do it again. but I agree with waiting. No need to open an account that you won’t use! 🙂
Steve says
Thanks for the comparisons. I just opened a Sharebuilder account for a $90 bonus through Costco. As I don’t really have any extra money to invest right now, I will most likely wait until TradeKing does some sort of bonus. The comparisons were very helpful though.
Ryan says
Brad: Thanks for the info. I have not had much exposure to TOS, which is why I did not mention them.
Am I missing something regarding the fees? You mentioned you pay $1 equity trades, but the TOS price sheet states that shares are $0.015 per share, with a $5 minimum, a $10 flat rate.
There are other good benefits at TOS – the three free mutual fund trades per month is nice, as are a few other features.
I guess I’m just curious to hear more info.
Ryan says
frugalcpa: If you know what you are doing, you can save a lot of money by eliminating the middle man. A professional advisor can benefit you though, because they will know certain things you won’t – such as allocation, tax laws, different places to invest, etc.
Just be careful you don’t let them sell you something you don’t need! 😉
Brad says
I recommend brokerages like Interactive Brokers or ThinkOrSwim who charge far less per transaction and you can truly manage your portfolio.
I trade with TOS and get $1 equity trades, $1.25 options, $2.50 futures. They have an outstanding software platform you can download or you can manage it online like rest of the companies out there. In addition, you get an internet rebate with 40 trades, 3 free mutual fund trades if that’s your thing, they cover $100 ACAT fees if transferring, etc., etc.
Joe says
I signed up with interactive brokers and they said they’re not running any promotions where they cover a ACAT fee
frugalcpa says
Great breakdown! When I have money to invest, I need to refer back to this to help me decide which online service to use. In the past I invested through Edward Jones, but I’m definitely going to bypass the middleman going forward.