Roth Conversions: Why Timing is Important

There is an ever-old discussion on the importance of saving for retirement.  And ever since the Roth IRA was created by the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, there’s been a similar discussion on whether you should contribute to a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA.  Finally, there has been just as much discussion on whether…
Advertising Disclosure.

Advertiser Disclosure: Opinions, reviews, analyses & recommendations are the author’s alone. This article may contain links from our advertisers. For more information, please see our Advertising Policy.

Roth Conversion Same Taxes

There is an ever-old discussion on the importance of saving for retirement.  And ever since the Roth IRA was created by the Taxpayer Relief Act of 1997, there’s been a similar discussion on whether you should contribute to a traditional IRA or a Roth IRA.  Finally, there has been just as much discussion on whether you should convert current traditional accounts to Roth accounts.

Since most people are eligible to take a tax deduction on their IRA contribution, this involves paying taxes on the conversion amount, then transferring the remainder to their Roth account.  However, there are many factors that can determine how beneficial Roth conversions can be.

In a previous case study article, we explored the impact of Roth conversions at various tax brackets.  Not surprisingly, the higher the tax bracket is, the less after-tax money is available in the Roth account.  However, this two-part article aims to discuss:

  • Tax-equivalency principle
  • The impact of tax rate changes on account values
  • Why tax rates might change over time
  • When you might take advantage of changing tax brackets to maximize account value
  • When you might not want to make Roth conversions to preserve value

Roth conversions:  Tax-Equivalency Principle

What’s the tax-equivalency principle?  Simply put, it states that as long as tax rates remain the same, two tax-advantaged accounts will yield the same after-tax amount, regardless of whether the contribution was taxed upon contribution or upon withdrawal.

For example, Jane and Joe each have $5,000, which are in traditional IRAs.  Jane decides to keep her traditional, and Joe into a Roth.  Both are in the 25% tax bracket, and remain so over time.  They also make identical investments.  Since Jane made her contribution on a pre-tax basis, she starts off with $5,000.  However, Joe has to pay taxes on his contribution, so he only starts with $3,750 ($5,000 minus 25%).

Let’s fast forward 20 years, when they plan to withdraw from their accounts.  Their identical investments have achieved an average annual return of 8%.  Jane would have $23,304.79, while Joe would only have $17,478.59.  However, when you tax Jane’s pre-tax IRA at 25%, her account ends up at $17,478.59…the same as Joe’s.  That’s the tax-equivalency principle:  assuming identical investments remain at the same tax rate over time, it doesn’t matter whether the contribution is taxed, or the withdrawal is taxed.

Roth Conversion Same Taxes

Of course, most people do not stay in the same tax bracket forever, so let’s look at what happens when tax rates change over time.

What would happen if Joe & Jane’s tax rates went up?

Using the previous example, let’s say that Joe & Jane are wildly successful over the course of their careers.  Instead of staying in the 25% tax bracket, they eventually move up to the 35% bracket.  How would this change their after-tax values?

Joe’s account value would stay the same-$17,478.59, since the change in tax bracket has no impact on his Roth account.  However, Jane’s account would only be worth $15,148.11 after taxes.  In this case, Joe paid taxes on his account at 25%, which allowed him to avoid paying taxes at 35% later on.

Roth Conversions Taxes Go Up

What would happen if Joe & Jane’s tax rates went down?

Instead of moving into the 35% tax bracket, let’s assume that Joe & Jane retire, and move into the 15% tax bracket.  How does their after-tax value change?

Joe’s account would still stay the same at $17,478.59.  However, Jane’s after-tax account value is now $19,809.07.  This makes sense because Jane only had to pay 15% on her account, whereas Joe paid 25% up front.

Roth Conversions Taxes Go Down

Conclusion

In both cases, the difference in account values reflects the impact of the change in marginal tax rate on investment returns.  The key point is that maximizing account values depends on being able to make conversions at low tax rates and avoid conversions at high tax rates.

The complexity is what happens when tax rates change over time.  The next article will outline how these changes might occur over the course of a military career, and illustrate opportunities to optimize your Roth conversions.

Get Instant Access
FREE Weekly Updates! Enter your information to join our mailing list.

Posted In:

About Forrest Baumhover

Forrest Baumhover is a Certified Financial Planner™ and financial planner with Lawrence Financial Planning, a fee-only financial services firm. As a retired naval officer, Forrest helps veterans, transitioning servicemembers and their families address the financial challenges of post-military life so they can achieve financial independence and spend more time doing the things they love.

Reader Interactions

Leave A Comment:

Comments:

About the comments on this site:

These responses are not provided or commissioned by the bank advertiser. Responses have not been reviewed, approved or otherwise endorsed by the bank advertiser. It is not the bank advertiser’s responsibility to ensure all posts and/or questions are answered.

The Military Wallet is a property of Three Creeks Media. Neither The Military Wallet nor Three Creeks Media are associated with or endorsed by the U.S. Departments of Defense or Veterans Affairs. The content on The Military Wallet is produced by Three Creeks Media, its partners, affiliates and contractors, any opinions or statements on The Military Wallet should not be attributed to the Dept. of Veterans Affairs, the Dept. of Defense or any governmental entity. If you have questions about Veteran programs offered through or by the Dept. of Veterans Affairs, please visit their website at va.gov. The content offered on The Military Wallet is for general informational purposes only and may not be relevant to any consumer’s specific situation, this content should not be construed as legal or financial advice. If you have questions of a specific nature consider consulting a financial professional, accountant or attorney to discuss. References to third-party products, rates and offers may change without notice.

Advertising Notice: The Military Wallet and Three Creeks Media, its parent and affiliate companies, may receive compensation through advertising placements on The Military Wallet; For any rankings or lists on this site, The Military Wallet may receive compensation from the companies being ranked and this compensation may affect how, where and in what order products and companies appear in the rankings and lists. If a ranking or list has a company noted to be a “partner” the indicated company is a corporate affiliate of The Military Wallet. No tables, rankings or lists are fully comprehensive and do not include all companies or available products.

Editorial Disclosure: Editorial content on The Military Wallet may include opinions. Any opinions are those of the author alone, and not those of an advertiser to the site nor of  The Military Wallet.