In the last few years, there have been several proposals and studies linked to the Department of Defense (DoD) closing U.S.-based Commissaries as a way to slash hundreds of millions of dollars from defense budgets. The issue has been pursued as far as requesting a written plan from the Defense Commissary Agency (DeCA) that would outline how DeCA would close all US Commissaries.
As of right now, the Commissaries haven’t been given the kiss of death. This is an initial step to investigate the process of closing the base grocery stores, create a timeline if the closures do come to pass, and investigate the impact this could have on the active duty and retiree communities.
Commissaries Feature Large Savings – But at a Cost
Like Base Exchanges, military Commissaries are a cherished privilege among military families, retirees, and the newly eligible disabled veterans and caregivers. They offer discounted grocery shopping, bulk discounts, and a place to shop within the base community. Most Commissaries also indirectly support ancillary businesses that set up shop outside the Commissary doors. Many of these small businesses are veteran-owned and cater specifically to the military community.
Unfortunately, most Commissaries don’t turn a profit. By design, Commissaries operate on a surcharge model, pricing their goods at cost, plus a small surcharge to help cover the cost of the goods sold. But the surcharge doesn’t cover the Commissary employees, who are federal workers.
Shoppers often save up to 30% compared to the cost of food and goods bought at local stores found off base. But this comes at a cost. According to Military.com, “Commissaries rely on taxpayer subsidies of $1.4 billion a year to operate 247 stores worldwide.”
That is a huge deficit at a time when the military is being tasked with butting $50 billion a year to meet the requirements of the sequestration. DoD leaders are tasked with finding means of reducing the budget without decimating total force strength and readiness numbers.
What Would Closing Commissaries Accomplish?
In a word – huge savings. Military.com quoted potential savings of up to $800 – $900 million a year by closing 180 US-based Commissaries. Overseas Commissaries, OCONUS Commissaries (e.g. Alaska and Hawaii), and 24 remote US Commissaries would remain open.
How Would Closures Affect the Military Community?
Let’s get the easy one out of the way: closing base Commissaries would remove huge cost savings for military members and retirees. Estimates put the savings at roughly 30% compared to shopping at civilian grocery stores, and a savings of up to $4,500 per year for a family of four. That is a large amount of money to come up with for a military family or a retiree on a fixed income (See Commissary website for numbers).
But closing base Commissaries would go far beyond the impact on the family food budget. Many military spouses and retirees are employed by Commissaries, and this would not only increase the family food budget, but it would reduce the family income as well. Working for a Commissary is also a portable job that can often be transferred when a family PCS’s to another base. Portable jobs aren’t always easy to come by for military spouses.
We also touched on related small businesses which often set up shop in the same building as Commissaries, or right outside the Commissary doors. These often include barbershops and beauty salons, gift stores, and other small businesses. Many of these are retiree- or veteran-owned and get the majority of their foot traffic directly from the Commissary.
Finally, the impact goes far beyond the impact on individuals – closing US-based Commissaries would impact the functionality of the Commissary program. The base Commissaries are a network of 247 stores, some of which are quite large and are high volume. This gives DeCA negotiating power when making purchases. Reducing the number of Commissaries reduces DeCA’s bargaining power, reducing the discounts they can achieve when making bulk purchases. The high-volume stores also help subsidize the lower volume stores, helping reduce the costs of maintaining those stores. In other words, closing the profitable stores may not have the anticipated long-term impact the government is seeking.
Alternatives to Closing US Base Commissaries
Closing Commissaries is only one option on the table. There are some other possibilities being examined, including increasing the surcharge from 5% to 10%. While this seems like a huge increase on the surface, Commissary prices are already 30% lower than other stores, making a 5% increase much more affordable to shoppers than closing the stores outright. Some experts estimate a 5% increase in the surcharge to cost a family of 4 less than $500 a year, bringing family savings to $4,000 or more a year.
Another option is increasing the costs of food and goods worldwide to reduce the deficit and help defray the costs of shipping goods overseas. A third option mentioned includes introducing new goods to sell for a profit, including some items not currently sold at Commissaries, such as wine, beer, and beauty supplies.
What Will Happen Next?
At this point, there has been a call for DeCA to create a plan to close US Commissaries, but the plan has yet to be completed or approved. If it is approved, it would likely be part of the 2015 budget proposal, which would put it a year out before we would see any action taken on this front. Even then, it would likely take several months to see closures take place.
The Commissaries are a huge part of the military and retiree community. It would be a shame to see them close. Hopefully, DeCA and the DoD will arrive at some alternative solution(s) to keep the Commissary doors open.